Sh'ma.com

May 2002  

 


 

   Home

    

    

    

  

    

   

    

    

    

    

 

 

 

 

 

 








May 2002 Highlights

Israel and the Diaspora

Sh'ma has received numerous letters to the editor about Nathan Lewin's essay, "Deterring Suicide Bombers." A Response from the Editor appears in the Letters to the Editor section.

Many thanks,
Susan

Note: The debate between Nathan Lewin and Arthur Green on how to deter suicide killers, which appears below, are two parts of a whole. Please do not circulate one article without the other.

Introduction We are now faced with an apparently intractable, increasingly ferocious Israeli-Palestinian conflict. This expanded issue of Sh'ma--offered only in part on-line--offers a series of perspectives on how American Jews might talk about the crisis. Some of the reflections might shock. These are shocking times, and that some are now thinking the unthinkable might well unsettle us. But the only way out of the present quagmire is to listen intently, to weigh previously inconceivable options, and to arrive at conclusions that contain just enough morality and just enough pragmatism. As usual, the opinions expressed in these articles do not necessarily reflect the views of the sponsors or the Sh'ma board. Feel free to participate in the conversation on-line.

 Stephen P. Cohen:
At the Crossroads

On September 11, the enemy of Israel and the enemy of America became the same enemy.

 

 David Makovsky:
Taking on the Ideology of Islamicism

Not taking on the ideology of Islamicism has disastrous consequences. Religious intolerance does not enable countries to adequately educate their next generation, create democracies, and grow their economies.

 Sidra DeKoven Ezrahi:
At the Divide

Because the Intifada is becoming uglier and bloodier by the hour, American Jews feel they can do little more than express "solidarity." We must do better.

 

 Nathan Lewin:
Detering Suicide Killers

Israel should, by "targeted assassinations" or other means, be free promptly to execute the immediate relatives of suicide bombers.

 

 Arthur Green:
A Stronger Moral Force

Israel is the creation of the entire Jewish people, and has to stand for something, not just survive by becoming a barbaric Middle Eastern superstate.

 

 Book Reviews

Steven T. Rosenthal's Irreconciliable Differences? The Waning of the American Jewish Love Affair with Israel offers a depressing overview of this dysfunctional relationship. - Review by Gil Troy

 Koret Foundation Sh'ma Book Reviews

 NiSh'ma

 

Life on the Fringes: A Feminist Journey Toward Traditional Rabbinic Ordination by Haviva Ner-David

Life on the FringesNew from Jewish Family & Life!, the parent organization of Sh'ma: Life on the Fringes, a moving memoir and halakhic commentary by a young Jewish feminist who is poised to become the first female Orthodox rabbi. The author, Haviva Ner-David, explores contemporary approaches to Jewish law and life, women's involvement in ritual and study, the challenges of parenting, gender and our Jewish journeys, and more ...

Click on the cover to order.


Living Words: Best High Holiday Sermons of 5760/1999
Living Words: The Best High Holiday Sermons of 5760 is a collection of sermons filled with words of wisdom, pleas for justice, tales of journeys and text-analyses that will inspire and enrich your soul as you ponder new teachings for the High Holidays. Selected by a panel of compassionate and thoughtful judges, these sermons are diverse and challenging, seeking to engage those individuals striving for both knowledge and spiritual growth.

For Sale: A New Source Book on the Jewish Ethics of Addressing Terrorism

This publication is designed to help individuals and families use Jewish sources and resources to address the aftermath of the terrorist attack in NY and Washington. The book asks: How do we do fight terrorism and preserve our society's moral fiber? How do we maintain our personal, communal and religious ethics and sense of morality in the face of a needed war on terrorism? What are the boundaries for addressing terrorism? What is the ethical framework we employ? :

Jewish Ethics and Fighting Terrorism will include three distinct sections:
1. Helping families and educators with strategies to address this difficult terrain with their children.
2. Several High Holiday Sermons that offer words of wisdom, inspiration, comfort, and insight into how an American Jewish community responds to terrorism.
3. An expanded special issue of Sh'ma that addressed these questions with essays from  Rabbi Saul Berman, Director of Edah, a voice of Modern Orthodoxy
Dr. Marc Gopin, author of Between Eden and Armageddon: The Future of World Religions, Violence and Peacemaking and Holy War, Holy Peace
Dr. Reuven Firestone, Professor of Medieval Judaism and Islam at HUC-JIR in LA and author of Jihad: THe Origin of Holy War in Islam.
Dr. Dov Zakheim, Undersecretary of Defence, Controller
Dr. Vanessa Ochs, Professor of Religion, University of Virginia
Rabbi Arnold Resnicoff, National Director of Inter-religious Affairs at the American Jewish Committee, former Chief Rabbi of the American Armed Services
Dr. Dawn Rose, former director of the Ethics Center at the Reconstructionist Rabbinical School and Rabbi of Temple of Universal Judaism in NYC.
Rabbi Yitz Greenberg, President of Jewish Life Network

Available February, 2002. $25.00 includes postage and handling. To order, contact stephenc@JFLmedia.com.



| home | about us | contact us | classifieds |
|
links | search | subscribe | write for us | support |

Join Sh'ma's
Online Discussion

In the spirit of sacred conversation, Sh'ma requests that the posting on this website reflect community of Sh'ma readers -- that is, be respectful, refrain from any anti-Semitic remarks, refrain from inflamatory rhetoric. Sh'ma will remove from the page any postings that do not comply with these guidelines.

How should Israel deter suicide bombers?

Post your thoughts!

Learn more about the Experiment in Congregational Education (ECE) and its work in transforming congregational education at www.eceonline.org



Quote of
the Month

"Many Jews from America have brought their own brand of self-ghettoization that stretches from day schools in New York to Efrata in the West Bank." Sidra DeKoven Ezrahi